It almost goes without saying that there are a large number of truly old homes in the historic district of Old Town Alexandria. As a whole, Old Town represents one of the most densely packed areas in the country when it comes to homes on the National Register of Historic places. While the area represents an important pocket of history in the United States and was one of the first few Federally recognized historic districts, quite a few of the homes have moderate to major historic significance on their own. One such home, the Dr. James Craik house, is the focus of today's Around Old Town.

Simply put, this house is gorgeous. There's just no other way to put it. It's grand, elegant, towering, a classic 18th century townhouse mansion, and an example of a restoration effort not often seen in the early to mid 20th century when similarly dilapidated homes would have been demolished. Just look at the state the house had fallen into by roughly 1930.

However, missing window panes, crumbling mortar, and overgrowth of ivy could do nothing to quash the importance of this home, so efforts to restore it and the neighboring wood frame flounder home to the left have been undertaken at several points since that old photo.

But what's the significance of these two homes? One name can begin to paint a picture. 

George Washington

When a site's importance can be quickly conveyed by a simple "George Washington slept here," "George Washington dined here," "George Washington originally owned this land," or "George Washington once thought earnestly about stopping by to ask for a glass of water," it's obvious just how important of a figure President Washington is to the history of America. These two homes (which are now a single dwelling) are absolutely steeped in Washington lore.

The larger home of the two, located at 210 Duke Street, was the home and office of Scottish surgeon, Dr. James Craik. 

Built for Dr. Craik in 1796 after his friend George Washington convinced him to move to Alexandria, Craik practiced medicine in the front of the home, while maintaining residence in the rear and on the upper floors. By the time this home was constructed, Dr. Craik had already established his place in history. He was a personal physician to George Washington, the Physician General of the Revolutionary Army, and was at Washington's side at nearly every battle from the French and Indian War through the Revolutionary War. At the time of Washington's death, Dr. Craik was one of the doctors at the iconic president's bedside, and many believe may have ironically been somewhat responsible for Washington's death by allowing Washington to be bleed (a common but becoming quickly antiquated process at the time) to resolve his illness, ultimately making him too weak to recover.

The second home, to the left of the Craik house, is the Coryell house. Today the home is covered in a brick veneer, but the little wood frame flounder home was lived in and may have been built by George Coryell in 1790.

The name Coryell is probably not immediately familiar but is also tied to George Washington's deep history. On Christmas Eve 1776, George Washington and his men stealthily crossed the Delaware River for a surprise attack on the Hessians. The moment, immortalized in this painting, took place on ferries owned and operated by the Coryell family.

Though this image is historic and amazing (with a copy even hanging in The White House), its artist played a little fast and loose with the historical facts. I found this very interesting article about a more accurate representation of what occurred that night, including the more correct style of ferry boat of the Coryell's they most likely used to cross the river. 

Mort Kunstler’s “Washington’s Crossing at McKonkey’s Ferry” 

Wendy and I tend to walk through the 200 block of Duke Street quite often, and we almost always marvel at the two houses in all of their grandeur, daydreaming about how amazing it could be to live there. We've had the opportunity to tour the home on a few occasions and can attest to the home's interior beauty as well as its functionality as a 21st century residence with all the modern conveniences one could hope for.

The home is so truly historic, but it's also set up to be lived in by a family. The yard is large, kitchen and bathrooms upgraded, and overall living space seems quite comfortable.

The current owners purchased the house several years ago and undertook a refresh effort to preserve the front of the home much as it would have been when it was Dr. Craik's office. They also had a painting made of George Washington visiting Dr. Craik in his office and hung it above the fireplace, showing what a scene in the 1790s may have looked like.

For us, the details of the home are truly wonderful. The long horse pass between the two structures is lined with three hanging copper gas lanterns.

This horse pass led to Dr. Craik's stables at the rear of the property. One of his stable buildings is now a garage at the rear of a home on adjacent Lee Street.

The original masonry in a Flemish bond, floor divisions visible by the masonry, 15 over 15, 12 over 12, 8 over 8, and original dormer window sash, as well as restored shutters with small copper caps to keep rain from penetrating and speeding rot in the exterior embellishment, all combine to make this home about as unique as they come.

And though I'd probably prefer that the flounder to the left have retained its clapboard siding, the fact a small wood frame flounder from 1790 is still standing in the same size and shape is quite amazing.

The small details of the home, such as the boot scrape just outside of the front door...

...or the horse head hitching post just outside of the front door continue the charm on a small scale level.

And a quick glance up to the copper roof reveals two large copper clad dormers of a rather spacious fourth floor.

Legend has it this house may also be one of the most haunted in Alexandria, and it has a lot to do with that fourth floor. But that's another blog story for another day.

Five stories of living space, a large yard with gardens, complete privacy, ideal location, a small historic structure, and historically accurate details throughout make this home perfect in our eyes. This is one of the homes that stands alone as a reason for Old Town Alexandria's designation as an historic district.

Do you have a favorite home in your neighborhood that you always pause to admire? Perhaps the home itself, a beautiful garden, interesting portico, or some other architectural feature that captivates you? If so, we'd love to hear all about it in the comment section, or snap a photo and send it to alex@oldtownhome.com for a chance to be featured in an upcoming "Around Town" segment.

Comments 10

Comments

7/18/2013 at 10:49 AM
Wow! I always walk by this house and wonder what it's like inside. And I had no idea that the adjoining flounder house was owned by Mr. Coryell (or, really, who Mr. Coryell was). What a great post, guys!
Alex
7/23/2013
Thanks, Cara!
7/18/2013 at 3:31 PM
Another great post about a beautiful brick Federal home. It's great that it was saved from continued decline in the 1930s.

Some of the older home magazines such as House Beautiful and House and Garden from the 1910s through the 1930s actually have a few pieces in them that talk about the restoration of historic "Colonial" homes, though it seems then that the term "Colonial" encompassed everything from the 1600s through 1840s Neoclassical Revivals, and the furnishing of such homes with original and reproduction antique pieces true to the style of the home. I think this was the true "birth" of house restoration, though it did not become widespread for several decades. I also think part of it had to do with the Colonial Revivals being the popular style of the period, much like how the 1940s-60s "Mid Century" craze is hitting now.

Thanks for the pictures and the history!
Alex
7/24/2013
In most people's vocabulary "Colonial" still represents "anything before the Civil War, so that's not surprising. It is a shame that true conservation and restoration was initially so limited to just "important" places. Alexandria lost so many great and truly historic architectural examples in the 1960s-1980.
Kelly C.
7/19/2013 at 12:07 PM
Wow, I totally enjoyed this! Can you imagine what it felt like to be the men packed on that ferry?? Really cool post, thanks!
Alex
7/24/2013
I'm willing to bet it was a mix of excitement, fear, and uneasiness about the battle...and about falling into the icy Deleware because giant canons and a ton of people were on a little ferry. But if GW was doing it, who was to tell him he was doing it wrong. :-)
Marissa
7/23/2013 at 2:52 AM
You are the source of a long-standing argument between me and my husband.
About a year ago, you wrote about the Francis Harper House and described the function of the horse pass. I thought this was so interesting because I'd always wondered what those arched alleys were for! So a few months later when my husband and I were walking through Old Town, I pointed out a horse pass and explained to him its function. He quickly disagreed and said it was impossible that a horse could fit through such a narrow entry. IMPOSSIBLE!!! Well, I've never ridden a horse (he has), but I let him know that I learned this fact from professional historic architects who blog in their spare time about notable old homes (I hope you like your new title). Now, every time we see a horse pass, we have this same argument. I've tried googling "horse pass", but can never find any reference to this feature. So please. Help me win this argument. Is there a book or official source that talks about this architectural element? I know you're right. I'm sure my husband just rode fat horses.
Alex
7/24/2013
I've looked high and low to back up what I've said with something mildly factual and reputable, but I've been unable to find anything other than a random mention about something similar in Philadelphia. I'll continue to look around and see if I can't find some information that can back up my claims.

However, the passages are narrow enough to fit a riderless horse. That's the key here, led by a person, not ridden by one.

And though we appreciate you thinking of us as "professional historic architects," we cannot claim this status. But we did stay at a Holiday Inn Express last night.
Marissa
7/30/2013 at 3:58 PM
Thanks so much for looking into it!

My husband's argument is actually about the width of the openings, not the height. He doesn't think a horse- even unsaddled- could fit through, and that even a skinny horse would scrape its sides. He's been known to exaggerate to win an argument (a habit I've picked up, apparently), so who knows?

Thanks again. I'll check back to see if you find anything. I'm 100% on Team Horse Pass.
10/7/2013 at 1:26 PM
Hurrah, that's what I was searching for, what a stuff! present here at this blog for <a href="www.lct.net.cn/special/lctuggs.php">????????</a>;, thanks admin of this site.
Since you've not signed in yet, you will need to fill in your name and email below. If you have a Facebook account, save yourself a step and use Connect to login.

Denotes a required field.

Please enter full URL, including http://

You can use Markdown syntax in your comment. And you can also use lots of Emoji!
  • Search

  • Login
  • Follow
  • Advertising

If you're looking for information on advertising and sponsorships, head on over to our sponsorships page. You can purchase site sponsorships in a few easy clicks. 

Toolbox Tuesday
Open Housing
  • Popular Topics
  • Comments
  • Blog Roll
  • We're Featured!

Old Town Home has been featured in the following places and publications:

The Washington Post
 
Washingtonian Magazine
 
Domino
 
Old House Journal
 
 
Apartment Therapy House Tour
 
Washington Post Express Feature
 
Home & Garden Blogs
 
© 2019 OldTownHome.com. - Privacy Policy
Login Below
or
Sign in with Facebook
Connect

Unexpected Error

Your submission caused an unexpected error. You can try your request again, but if you continue to experience problems, please contact the administrator.

Working...

Working...